
What, Me Repressed?
The Magellan's Log Test of Reality-denial
by the Staff of Magellan's Log
I was born to shiver the in the draft of an open mind.
Samson Shillitoe, in A Fine Madness by Elliot Baker.
(Click here if you want to skip our elegantly phrased, fairly
funny introduction and go directly to the repression test.)
One problem with us inhabitants of the new millennium, however edenic it may be,
is that we tend to view the pre-millennial past with just a smidgen too much scorn.
Especially the 20th century.
Why, we seem to have decided, should we take seriously any era that:
1) had no cell phones,
2) spent more time worrying about hair care than erectile
dysfunction, and
3) thought that having got rid of Hitler and the Soviet
Union
that was pretty much it as far as
Evil was concerned?
Certainly the 20th century left a lot to be desired, but its beginning to become
clear that too often in reacting to that troubled age, weve thrown out the
baby with the bath water.
Take Freud for example. As the century waned, the only people still taking Freud
seriously were the French, and their highfalutin thinkers used him just as a springboard
to launch themselves into a glorious, abstract wonderland with a single rule: All is
theory.
Freud didnt get everything, not by a long shot, but he got a lot,
from religion (Moses and Monotheism) to violence (Civilization and Its
Discontents) to stand-up comedians (Jokes and Their Relation to the Unconscious).
One of the big losses when we tossed ol "Biology-Is-Destiny/Penis-Envy"
Sigmund out the window was his (pardon the expression) theory of repression, which reduced
to its most basic form, stated:
1) Shit happens, and
2) We mostly contrive to forget the shit that
has happened.
(Naturally theres a lot more to it than this, as Freud spent some decades of his
tormented life pointing out, but as New Millennialists we when faced with a choice between
short-and-sweet and complex-and-bitter choose to simplify, simplify, simplify, which among
other things explains both George W. Bush and the popularity of SUVs, but
thats a whole other story.)
Any half-awake observer of the human comedy can only nod and between the tears of
laughter and tragedy, affirm, "Right on, Siggy. We ARE repressing like hell
but we just dont KNOW it!"
Turn on the TV, attend a church service or a political rally. Hell, hang around outside
your bathroom door for a while. Whatever we officially think about Freud,
repression reigns.
Bigtime.
Still.
The question is NOT "Are you repressed?" The question is "HOW
repressed are you?"
Any way you look at itphilosophically, theologically, scientifically,
free-market-lysome repression is good. I mean, if we dont repress at least a
little bit we cant get out of bed in the morning.
By the same token, too much repression can lead to abjectand extremely
hazardousdenial of reality and belief in castles-in-the-air, resulting in
delusional societies of the most dangerous sort. Maoists, Mouseketeers, Microsofts,
Baptists, Republicans, Free-Marketeers: all sterlingand frighteningall
examples of repression run amok.
The more accurate question then is: Are you TOO repressed? Have you,
with the best of self-interested intentions, inadvertently gone that one tiny step too far
in DENYING STUFF?
Why, you perhaps ask, is too much repression a bad thing? Whats
wrong if youve by hook, crook, or sheer luck got yoursyour gated-community
house here and your condo in Aspen, your stock portfolio, your his-'n'-her Hummers, and
now youre trucking along comfortably, so whats wrong with that?
Whats wrong with that? Does the expression "house of cards"
meaning anything to you?
The danger is, your repression becomes so nearly perfect that you
begin to see yourself assorry, theres no other way to put thissafe.
Impregnable, so to speak (pace, Sigmund).
One thing any less-than-perfectly repressed sentient being quickly realizes is that no
one, nowhere, no-time, is safe. Mostly safe? Sure. Often safe? Sure. But never, ever
really, really safe the way the truly repressed think they are.
Yes, Virginia, there is a world, quite a vast world out there, and yes, dear, we are,
like it or not, part of that world. No amount of denial or repression changes that
fact.
Our taskOK, one of our tasksis to figure out a way to balance our egotistic
cleverness with our undeniable (if not always entirely clear) place in the larger, often
chaotic, sometimes dangerous order of things.
Not to despair. Such a balancing act is possible, as for several
millennia the few wise humans who survived the repressive ministrations of their less-wise
fellows long enough to utter a few pithy sayings have repeatedly reminded us.
So. Are you TOO repressed? Heres your chance to find out:
Click here to go The Magellan's Log
Test of Reality-denial. >>
Back to Magellan's
Log 84
Magellan's
Log front page
Send this page to a friend.

|