
Beyond Venturi
Son of Learning from Las Vegas
by Sawyer Brown
I recently got it into my head that I needed to drive from Houston
to Los Angeles.
The proposed route pretty well mapped itself. I wanted to
re-visit a couple of the small towns in the Panhandle of Texas, where I grew up. That
would take me north to Dalhart (upper left corner of the state). There being no Interstate
from Dalhart to L.A. via Las Vegas, a not unattractive northerly detour through Colorado
and Utah seemed called for.
Which would bring me into Las Vegas from the northeast,
itself a highly attractive strategy. Think about it: the other way in, the road from L.A.
to Vegas is special, if not sacred. Did I want to even try to follow in Dr. Thompsons
inimitable tire tracks? The thought of plunging into the Great American Architectural
Icon out of the less-traveled, surely less-venerated Utahite desert sounded just right.
Day 1
From Houston, getting out of Texas is uphill all the way, as one has to climb from sea
level toward the backbone of the continent. Arriving on the once-barren but now
much-irrigated High Plains northwest of Wichita Falls, I was struck by a forgotten memory
and a forgotten dream.
At a rest area near Chillicothe, featuring a few concrete
tables and the only trees for miles, I was, Proust-like, transported to the past, not by
odor but by sound: birdsong. I had forgotten that, for all the barrenness, the Texas
plains, wherever theres a tree or two, are haven for more birds than anyone has a
right to expect.
Aurally refreshed, I drove on, and on. And on. And up. The
air became clearer and cooler. The inhabitants gave up irrigating, then tried for a few
hundred miles to let cattle subsist on the scrub, and finally said to heck with it and
just let the land be, in all its vast, cracked, brown aridity. I loved it. This was my
childhood home. I was comfortable, contented in the middle of what, to the doughty
Europeans who had to cross it last century, was hostile, threatening, dangerous
nothingness. I drove and smiled: it was beautiful.
I was home, after a fashion. Not
home-this-is-where-I-want-to-stay, but
home-this-is-the-place-that-taught-me-the-concept-home. I was as contented as the
Europeans must have been tense when they moved across the American desert at foot- or
horse-pace. Oh how, hiding their fear, they must have hated it. Oh how they took their
fear out on the Indians who, by all accounts, also felt at home here. Fearing or hating,
they hoped, and struggled through endless grasslands only to be faced then with endless
desert, then endless mountains, then more desert, then more mountains, and still more
mountains, only to arrive in California, which needed a lot of work, or so they thought.
Happily, with a John D. MacDonald
novel in the tapedeck, I drove through hours of not being fenced in, under not-cloudy
skies, neither heard nor thought a discouraging word. Far from any Interstate, traffic was
light, a car every five miles, and the towns of my childhood wereanother
surpriseholding their own against the onslaught of 20th century-dom. McDonalds
were the exception; carefully tended and re-re-painted Dairy Kings were the
rule. Time had not stopped (the omnipresent satellite dishes offered proof), but
everywhere was preserved a structural proof of the reality of the past, of my childhood:
yes, Sawyer, there was a time before this time of urban leveling. Not merely preserved,
but lived in, businessed in. Used. There were real buildings and houses in real towns
where people were still living and working. So what if they had some problems with
Lettermans skewed coastal humor, so what if their teenagers did their best as
mid-continent and Gap-less MTV poseurs, so what if even the wide places in the road now
had a Chinese restaurant, so what if the fine old brick buildings that once sold Nashes
and Hudsons now dispensed Toyotas and Hondas. The built environment that I remembered, and
that I now remembered as having shaped me, was there, still in place, still functioning
and aging very nicely. Home.
Day 2
Onward and upward over Raton Pass with its sudden horizon-to-horizon view of the
white-coated Rockies. White: not smog-orange, not grunge-gray, but white, dazzling,
test-your-Ray-Bans-on-this white. West through canyons that Hollywood had never
photographed (too deep for good light, too narrow for long-shots), past hippie ranchettes
with rusting 68 Beetles in the front yard and chortling mountain streams in the back
and by the road a galvanized RFD mailbox announcing with all the enigmatic grandeur of a
peace sign, "Where's Ed Sanders when we need him?".
Into truck-farming valleys, more mountains, over the
continental divide at 11,000 feet and fields of snow, more valleys, more mountains, and
the vegetation weakened, the trees first shortened, then diminished to sage and cactus,
and at last to splotches of desperate, thirsty grass as giant rock formations protruded
above and dominated the parched planetary skin.
By this time I was listening to Jacob Needleman reading the
Tao Te Ching and guessing that the legendary Mr. Lao-Tze would also have felt right at
home in this minimalist xeriscape. Might, I wondered, he have sat in the shade of similar
barren monoliths in far Western China to get to that awesome internal space which he then
tried to tell us about in a mere 5,000 words? I feel geomantically illiterate. A Cinerama
landscape enlarged a hundred times, gigaphonic letters, words, sentences, whole books in
every direction, but Im in first grade again. "Run, Spot, run!"
I stop. I look, I listen. I think: in car comfort, with the
noisome natives long-since dispatched to out-of-sight, out-of-mind concentration camps,
the word for it, for this this-ness, this big earth/little person/really big sky duality
is not "hostile" but "austere." A geographic sackcloth and ashes.
Day 3
Sleep in Utah, up before dawn for the dash into Nevada. This is typical, insensitive
urbanist timing on my part, because it means I drive through the Canyonlands and Arches
area in the dark. By the time the sun comes up behind me, I am into desert again with
mountains like some giants inscrutable purple calligraphy scrawled on the horizon.
Anticipation builds as the mileage signs count down to you-know-where.
Mount a rise, the land falls away into one of those basins
which surely seemed endless and uncountable to the Europeans trekking this way. This one
must be at least fifty miles across to the mountains in the west, and its north-south
dimension belies guessing. The last mileage sign had said: Las Vegas 25. I look, and I
look again. Finally, I squint and there in the middle of the bottom of the basin I make
out a tiny, sort of gray-to-black smudge. I squint some more, and I see tiny buildings in
the middle of the tiny smudge. Aha.
Las Vegas. A tiny
nothing in the middle of a vast something, a profound much-more-than-something. Las Vegas:
A mote in Gods eye?
I stop, and look, and think, and feel.
The stopping, looking, thinking, and feeling coalesce into
one short sentence: The continent and with it, the earth, may win after all. Will win. The
continent as teacher: a huge powerful and very patient though not entirely unforgiving
teacher.
It had taken me two and a half days of driving to get to my
goal. This grand American creation of something out of "nothing" turns out in
the larger, significant scheme of things to be, well, not nothing, but about as close to
nothing as you can get. A tiny, tiny smudge on a landscape whose age mocks everything we
hold dear.
Las Vegas: us doing our ultimate European impression of
hubris. Desert? What desert? Nothing a few dams and airports and highways cant fix.
Heat? Nothing a few mega-b.t.u.s of a/c cant handle. Shelter? Nothing a few
sheds and ducks (built to proportions the Gothic cathedral builders never dreamed of)
wont take care of.
The Europeans pretty quickly filled up Europe once they
began to get the hang of urban civilization. Among their many mistakes, one of the least
bloody was geographical. They started talking about Europe as a continent when in fact
Europe is, as the old gag has it, only a minor promontory on the west coast of Asia.
Its a gag but it happens to be true. And the Europeans geographic blunder
turned out to be costly. Because they came to think that a continent was something they
could handle, manage, subdue, and civilize, and finally urbanize. They did that to
their little promontory, with much warfare and also much hubris. Then, after the word
"Mediterranean" turned out to be an embarrassing and provincial misnomer, they
crossed a real ocean. First they encountered exploitable forest. No problem; well
make a little Europe here. Next they found a thousand miles of farmable land. No problem;
we can do a large bread basket here.
But then came mountains, more mountains than a hundred
Switzerlands, and enough desert to swallow and digest a million, a billion anchorites
without burping.
Sitting by the highway on that rise, squinting at my goal,
I had to ask, What did we learn from it all?
Sheds and ducks. Robert Venturi's terms, in his benchmark
book, Learning from Las Vegas, for the absurd
architectural simulacrums and false-fronted re-creations that now line the Strip.
After a while, I drove into Las Vegas proper. Boy, did we
ever learn sheds and ducks.
One can only be impressed that Venturi saw with such clear
eyes thirty years ago when, before American optimism had to face the challenge of a decade
of greed which would have made even J.P. Morgan wince, the world still seemed quite doable
in whatever way we sons (and parenthetical daughters) of Achilles and Odysseus and Oedipus
et al. might decide was proper. Such as the way of ducks and sheds.
Where others who bothered to look at Las Vegas saw at best
pop culture gaud, Venturi glimpsed not just irony, but American irony, the irony of the
American past, present, and future unless we change our ways. So, in the same decade that
Mailer figured out why we were in Vietnam, Venturi figured out why we were in Las Vegas.
His book, published in 1968 and still in print, is called "Learning from Las
Vegas."
Now as our un-self-conscious, adolescent irony of that time
is forced to become self-conscious and adult and responsible, Las Vegas still has
something to teach us. Not of course what Bugsy Siegal had in mind and not even, for all
his extraordinary, almost preternatural insight, what Venturi had in mind.
The lesson this time is, I think, rather more what the
continent has in mind for any creatures who happen to set up housekeeping on it. What is
it? I dont know. Try Lao-Tze for starters.
Better: Get thee to a desert.

Send this page to a friend.
For more info, see the page at amazon.com:
"Learning from Las Vegas"
Magellan's Log
front page |